Want to Know The Problem With Bathtub Lining? We’ll Examine the Pros and Cons

Bathtubs are often the centrepiece of any bathroom, serving as a place to unwind or relax after a long day. However, after years of use, your current outdated bathtub becomes worn or even damaged. This leaves homeowners searching for solutions to restore its beauty as well as its function. Bathtub lining might be an attractive feature that promises a quick and easy fix rather than an entire bathroom overhaul, but there are some issues to consider. Ottawa bathtub remodeling experts are the pros at providing bathroom remodeling solutions. We encourage you to learn about bathtub liners and why they might not be the best choice.

When considering a bathtub liner installation, exploring alternative options that will provide longer-lasting plus durable solutions is important. Bytown Better Bathtubs & Showers is your leading company of bathroom renovations in Ottawa. We offer several customizable options that will transform your bathroom into a relaxing oasis. Count on our local, experienced professionals to make your bath dreams come true with a one-of-a-kind bathtub remodelling service.

But before that, let’s examine the problem of bathtub lining by weighing out the pros and cons.

The Problem With Bathtub Lining? Pros & Cons

What Is A Bathtub Liner?

A bathtub liner is a custom-fit shell that is placed over an existing tub to cover up any chips, cracks, or stains. These liners are typically made from PVC, acrylic, or polystyrene and are marketed as a cost-effective alternative to a full tub replacement. While a bathtub liner may seem like an attractive option at first glance, there are several reasons why these PVC or acrylic covers are not the best choice.

A bathtub liner is not a cleaner option as they tend to trap dirt plus grime between the liner and the original tub. Additionally, the plastic material of the liner may become discoloured or warped over time, detracting from the bathroom's overall appearance. Lastly, a bathtub liner can actually cause more harm than good by trapping moisture between the liner and the original tub, leading to the growth of mould and mildew. Let's explore the pros and cons of the liner in Ottawa homes:

Pros Versus Cons of A Bathtub Lining


  • Offers a partial bathroom remodel

  • Durable, safe, easy to maintain

  • They save money compared to a full replacement

  • Installation is typically quicker & easier


  • The plastic material becomes discoloured or warped over time, detracting from the appearance of your bathroom as there is a constant dirty bathtub look

  • Water may get trapped between the liner and the old tub, potentially leading to odours, mould, as well as mildew growth

  • Doesn't provide the nice sensory feeling that an actual tub does, due to its plasticlike appearance

  • Bathtub liners may not be able to address underlying issues, such as leaks or structural damage to an original tub

  • Acrylic, fibreglass, and freestanding claw-foot bathtubs can't be lined as the common tub sizes or materials make it impossible, plus, they must connect to a wall

  • They can be difficult to clean and maintain

  • Bathtub lining could end up costly depending on the specifications of your tub or what model you choose

  • There are limited colour selections or outer surface options, such as shapes, internal measurements, or finished appearances

  • They only last 3 to 5 years, meaning it is a short-term fix plus, will need to be redone frequently

Weighing the cons against the pros, a complete bathtub replacement offers more benefits. With a new bathtub installation, you’ll be able to address underlying issues, prevent mould growth or water from being trapped, as well as ensure your bathroom is structurally sound and safe. Additionally, a new tub can significantly enhance your bathroom's overall look and feel, providing a long-lasting and durable solution that will stand the test of time. Investing in a replacement bathtub can create a beautiful plus functional bathroom that will provide a relaxing oasis for years to come.

Top 4 Problems That Can Arise From A Bathtub Liner

If you're considering a bathtub liner as a quick fix for your bathroom, it's important to be aware of some top problems that can arise:

  1. Poor installation: Since a tub liner is a thin plastic sheet installed over your existing bathtub, it requires precise measurements and careful installation. If the liner is not properly installed, water can seep between the liner and the original tub, leading to mould or mildew growth. Furthermore, it can also loosen any adhesive, creating a floating feeling when it separates from the actual tub.

  2. Difficult to clean: They can be difficult to clean as well as maintain. They require specialized cleaning products and tools to ensure they stay looking new. Over time, the plastic material of the liner can become discoloured or warped, detracting from the appearance of your bathroom.

  3. Limited durability: The plastic material of a liner is not as durable as other materials, such as acrylic or fibreglass. Over time, the liner can become brittle, crack, or puncture, which can lead to water damage and costly repairs.

  4. Masking underlying issues: Tub liners can only cover up surface-level issues with your original bathtub. They do not address any underlying issues, such as leaks or structural damage. Any problems with your original tub will still be present and could worsen over time.

While liners may seem like an attractive option, a full bathtub installation is the best choice for those seeking a long-lasting and durable solution. With Bytown's customizable colour choices, layout options, and experienced professionals, you can transform your bathroom into a beautiful and functional space you'll love for years. Talk to our installation experts at Bytown today to schedule a consultation and take the first step toward creating your dream higher-end appearance bathroom.

Experience the Bytown Difference: Your Alternative to Bathtub Lining That Lasts Years!

Bytown Better Bathtubs & Showers offers a full range of installation options that address all of these problems. With our experienced professionals, detailed measurements, and careful installation, you can trust that your new bathtub will be installed correctly and prevent any potential water damage. Additionally, the high-quality materials used by Bytown, such as acrylic and fiberglass, provide long-lasting durability, so you won't have to worry about costly repairs down the road.

When choosing Bytown, you can create a beautiful plus functional bathroom that will last for years to come. Contact our professional, friendly customer service representatives today at (613)909-4602 to schedule a consultation to start your bathroom renovation journey.

Schedule a FREE


with our team
© 2024 Bytown Better Bathtubs & Showers. All Rights Reseved

*Upon Approved Credit. Not available in Quebec.