Planning a bathroom renovation? One of the biggest decisions is choosing between a shower remodel and a bathtub remodel. While each offers its benefits in terms of comfort, design, and function, many homeowners ask the same question: Which option is more affordable?
The answer isn't black or white. The cost varies based on materials, labour, plumbing, and structural considerations - and choosing the right remodel also depends on your lifestyle needs and long-term goals.
Comparing the Cost: Shower Remodel vs. Tub Remodel
On the surface, it might seem that one option should be more affordable than the other, but that is not always the case. Shower and tub remodels often fall within a similar price range once you consider all factors: materials, labour, and any plumbing or structural adjustments.
"They're so close in price," says William Culleton, a tub and shower specialist. "I wouldn't say one is way more than the other."
While a basic shower base may cost less upfront than a high-quality tub, those savings can quickly level out depending on the scope of work. For instance, installing a custom tile shower or adding glass doors can drive up the price.
Meanwhile, a low-cost tub from a box store may seem like a deal, but it often compromises on structure and longevity.
"You get what you pay for," William Culleton adds. "Spending more gets you better insulation, better structure, and a tub that'll last."
Bottom line? True affordability is not just about upfront cost. It's about what works best for your space and lifestyle.
Shower Remodel
A shower remodel typically involves updating your existing enclosure, which may involve replacing the base, upgrading wall panels, installing new fixtures, or adjusting the plumbing layout.
There are two main types of shower bases to choose from: acrylic and custom tile. Acrylic bases are more affordable and faster to install, making them a popular choice for many homeowners. Custom tile bases, while offering a more high-end, personalized look, require more time and labour to complete.
"Installing a tiled shower is not a quick job," says William Culleton, professional tub and shower specialist. "You're waterproofing, levelling, prepping - it all adds up."
In terms of plumbing, showers often require more structural or drainage adjustments. Curtis McGrath, a licensed plumber and tub and shower specialist, explains: "A bathtub will always have drainage on one side, but showers could have it central or offset. That can complicate installation if there are beams or HVAC systems in the way.”
Shower remodels are ideal if:
You want a barrier-free or accessible design for mobility needs;
You're planning for resale value, especially in adult-focused homes;
You're short on space and want a clean and minimal layout; and
You prefer a modern and sleek look without bulky fixtures.
👉 Planning a shower remodel? Check out our guide: Pick Your Shower Base!
Bathtub Remodel
A tub remodel involves replacing or upgrading your current bathtub. This can range from a simple swap with a new acrylic tub to a more complex upgrade, such as installing a deeper soaker or a freestanding unit with custom tile surrounds.
Many homeowners are surprised by how much the quality of the tub affects the overall cost. William Culleton notes that there's a big difference between a budget tub and a premium model in terms of insulation and structure.
"A $300 tub might look fine," he says, "but it's not going to perform like a well-built, properly insulated one."
Bathtubs usually require fewer plumbing or structural adjustments, especially if you're swapping one tub for another in the same location.
Bathtub remodels are ideal if:
You have children or elderly family members who need easier bathing
You enjoy soaking and hydrotherapy for relaxation
You prefer a simpler installation with fewer plumbing surprises
👉 Planning a tub remodel? Select the Ideal Tub Base: Read More!
Start Your Remodel with Confidence
No two bathrooms are the same, and no two homeowners are either. At Bytown Better Bathtubs and Showers, we understand how personal this decision can be, and that's why we’re here to guide you through it.
Whether you prefer a walk-in shower or a luxurious soaking tub, our team ensures that your renovation is done right from start to finish. We combine premium materials and local expertise to deliver results that last.
Call Bytown Better Bathtubs and Showers Today!
📞 Contact us now at bytownbath.com or (613) 909-4704 to schedule your tub or shower remodel. Enjoy a remodel tailored to your home and budget!